In 2004, I wrote an article on how prolific the environmental insurance
marketplace was becoming.
Back then, there were "several options" available to insureds that allowed them to
effectively cap or contractually transfer their liabilities for known environmental
matters. Coverages or policies such as remediation cost cap, guaranteed cost to closure,
blended finite risk programs, and contractual transfer of liabilities were some of the
options available to property sellers and buyers 20-plus years ago. Those who took
advantage of such programs saw how rigorous it was to secure coverage and may also have
witnessed how such a simple concept could easily turn on the insurance industry.
Back then, I stated the following.
Environmental insurance has undergone a dramatic evolution over the past 20 years through the expansion of coverages and implementation of new and innovative applications. Up until recently, environmental insurance was mainly an effective tool for managing unknown environmental issues but had limited solutions to manage known environmental liabilities. As often happens, the "gap" in the market is being closed through the development of creative risk management tools. The emerging tools in the marketplace now allow insureds to effectively cap or contractually transfer their liabilities for known environmental matters. The implications are significant, as there are an increasing number of tools available to manage potentially catastrophic known environmental liabilities.
I can still say that the environmental insurance marketplace has undergone a
dramatic evolution, but today, I have to add that the marketplace has contracted when it
comes to effective options, as I mentioned above. Don't get me wrong, today we have more
insurers offering pollution legal liability (PLL) or "site coverage" (this is the base
coverage that the above products were built upon) than we have ever had. At last count,
we are probably at nearly 40 markets! All are offering some form of PLL coverage, but a
limited few offer cost cap or remediation stop-loss today, and I am not aware of any
insurers offering finite risk programs on a commercial basis. Of course, appetite varies
dramatically as well as capacity, length of policy term, and coverage itself.
Since we are on the subject, it appears to me that the market has seen many
new enhancements to PLL programs. In my view, the market may benefit from focused
product development, solid and sound underwriting, and consistent claims servicing,
particularly as options for insuring per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances liability and
contamination remain limited. In other words, we should focus less on the "gimmicky"
type of enhancements and get back to basics.
So, back to the original topic—where can organizations go for properties with
existing environmental problems or contamination? The short answer is there are a
limited few; maybe one or two markets offer certain coverages that we saw offered in the
late 1990s/early 2000s. The primary product available today is what is referred to as
remediation stop-loss or cost cap. Finite risk programs and environmental liability
buyouts, which were a heavy mix of both insurance and contractual risk transfer, are no
longer commercially available in the marketplace.
Before we move forward, it's important to review the benefits of the "base"
insurance product in many of these programs—PLL—the most common environmental insurance
product available to property owners in the insurance marketplace today.
PLL Insurance Details
For many owners of real estate, PLL can serve as a foundational environmental insurance product because it addresses both regulatory and civil liability exposures associated with contaminated properties. PLL policies are designed to protect owners against environmental liabilities arising from pollution conditions on, at, under, or emanating from an insured property.
Today, PLL policies have generally become more compartmentalized, meaning, where in the past one insuring agreement addressed all risks, today there tends to be different insuring agreements for certain aspects of coverage. For example, coverage typically includes varying insuring agreements such as those below.
Bodily injury (BI) and property damage (PD) for third-party claims for preexisting pollution conditions (not identified or discovered yet)
BI/PD for third-party claims for newly created pollution conditions on the
property
Cleanup cost for third-party claims resulting from pollution conditions
Cleanup cost for pollution conditions on the property itself
BI/PD and cleanup costs for pollution conditions arising out of transportation
BI/PD and cleanup costs for disposing of waste/materials at disposal sites
or "nonowned location or disposal sites"
Microbial matter/Legionella insuring agreements may be included and apply
separately to third-party BI/PD claims, cleanup costs, new and/or preexisting
coverages.
This compartmentalization allows insurers to apply certain
coverages even if known conditions exist where, once upon a time, if there were
preexisting issues, coverage would be denied. For example, there may be
polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) contamination on the property looking to be insured.
Since PCBs are sparingly soluble in water and adsorb in soil organic matter and
sediment particles rather than dissolving into percolating groundwater, a PLL
underwriter may take the position that, since PCBs are fairly immobile and the risk
of such contamination moving off-site is slim, they can offer BI/PD and cleanup
costs coverage for third-party claims but exclude the on-site cleanup coverage for
that property. This can be applied to other types of contamination as well.
Duration of the PLL term can vary as well. For transactional
purchases, terms vary between 5 and 10 years with a few insurers offering 10-year
policies for operational coverage, while others offer 10-year terms for
transactions. In regard to hospitality, habitational, and healthcare risks, most
markets offer a maximum term of 3 years, with a few offering up to a 5-year term;
however, for prospective or "operational" coverage, the average term is 3 years.
With around 40 insurers offering some type of PLL coverage, in our
experience it can be structured with limits of liability up to $300 million each
pollution condition/$300 million aggregate structured with various insurers offering
follow form excess of a primary PLL program.
Remediation Stop-Loss/Cost Cap Programs
When contamination is already known and a cleanup plan has been
established (and approved by a regulatory authority), remediation stop-loss or cost
cap insurance can provide valuable protection. These policies are frequently used
when remediation costs are difficult to estimate, subsurface conditions are found to
be uncertain (which is the majority of the time), complex contamination exists, or
there are expected regulatory requirements in that jurisdiction.
Cost cap coverage is designed to provide greater certainty to property owners, lenders, developers, and investors by limiting the financial impact of unforeseen remediation cost overruns. Cost cap policies typically pay for the expense incurred by the property owner when actual remediation expenses exceed anticipated cleanup costs. Coverage is typically structured around the following.
Significant investigative action resulting in a proven and comprehensive remediation budget
A significant self-insured retention structured above the total cost of expected remediation
Coinsurance may also apply depending on the type of contamination/cleanup plan
While the cost cap market is much more limited than the broader PLL sector, there are a few environmental insurers continuing to offer solutions. The process to obtain such insurance is a comprehensive and lengthy one, in some cases, taking more than a year to construct. For well-defined remediation projects supported by detailed site investigations, engineering estimates, and regulatory oversight, the process may be a bit easier, but owners may wish to take into consideration that the process is long and arduous, nonetheless.
As the redevelopment of contaminated properties continues and
stakeholders seek greater financial certainty, cost cap insurance can be an
important risk financing tool that the financial impact that unexpected cleanup cost
escalation can present. Lastly, the cost cap program is typically accompanied by a
traditional PLL policy for the unknown environmental conditions that could be
discovered during the actual remediation of the property as well as third-party
claims for bodily injury and property damage for both known and unknown pollution
conditions.
A More Comprehensive Solution?
So, where can owners of contaminated property turn to minimize the
risk of environmental liability? In addition to the above insurance mechanisms,
owners have other alternatives; however, there may not be one single tactic, but
rather a combination including but not limited to the following.
Environmental due diligence. Phase I or Phase II investigations may be conducted to identify potential environmental conditions.
Contractual risk transfer. Environmental
indemnities and hold harmless agreements from the seller of the property and
escrow agreements to fund future cleanup may be consented to.
Voluntary state cleanup programs. Many
states offer programs that provide liability protections for purchasers who did
not cause the contamination and reduced cleanup standards based on future land
use.
Although liability transfer provisions do not eliminate an owner's environmental obligations, they can help offset financial losses associated with contamination events. Used alongside environmental insurance and cleanup programs, these measures can enable property owners to better manage existing and future environmental risks, improve the marketability of their assets, and strengthen redevelopment and lending opportunities.
Opinions expressed in Expert Commentary articles are those of the author and are not necessarily held by the author's employer or IRMI. Expert Commentary articles and other IRMI content do not purport to provide legal, accounting, or other professional advice or opinion. If such advice is needed, consult with your attorney, accountant, or other qualified adviser.
In 2004, I wrote an article on how prolific the environmental insurance marketplace was becoming. Back then, there were "several options" available to insureds that allowed them to effectively cap or contractually transfer their liabilities for known environmental matters. Coverages or policies such as remediation cost cap, guaranteed cost to closure, blended finite risk programs, and contractual transfer of liabilities were some of the options available to property sellers and buyers 20-plus years ago. Those who took advantage of such programs saw how rigorous it was to secure coverage and may also have witnessed how such a simple concept could easily turn on the insurance industry.
Back then, I stated the following.
I can still say that the environmental insurance marketplace has undergone a dramatic evolution, but today, I have to add that the marketplace has contracted when it comes to effective options, as I mentioned above. Don't get me wrong, today we have more insurers offering pollution legal liability (PLL) or "site coverage" (this is the base coverage that the above products were built upon) than we have ever had. At last count, we are probably at nearly 40 markets! All are offering some form of PLL coverage, but a limited few offer cost cap or remediation stop-loss today, and I am not aware of any insurers offering finite risk programs on a commercial basis. Of course, appetite varies dramatically as well as capacity, length of policy term, and coverage itself.
Since we are on the subject, it appears to me that the market has seen many new enhancements to PLL programs. In my view, the market may benefit from focused product development, solid and sound underwriting, and consistent claims servicing, particularly as options for insuring per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances liability and contamination remain limited. In other words, we should focus less on the "gimmicky" type of enhancements and get back to basics.
So, back to the original topic—where can organizations go for properties with existing environmental problems or contamination? The short answer is there are a limited few; maybe one or two markets offer certain coverages that we saw offered in the late 1990s/early 2000s. The primary product available today is what is referred to as remediation stop-loss or cost cap. Finite risk programs and environmental liability buyouts, which were a heavy mix of both insurance and contractual risk transfer, are no longer commercially available in the marketplace.
Before we move forward, it's important to review the benefits of the "base" insurance product in many of these programs—PLL—the most common environmental insurance product available to property owners in the insurance marketplace today.
PLL Insurance Details
For many owners of real estate, PLL can serve as a foundational environmental insurance product because it addresses both regulatory and civil liability exposures associated with contaminated properties. PLL policies are designed to protect owners against environmental liabilities arising from pollution conditions on, at, under, or emanating from an insured property.
Today, PLL policies have generally become more compartmentalized, meaning, where in the past one insuring agreement addressed all risks, today there tends to be different insuring agreements for certain aspects of coverage. For example, coverage typically includes varying insuring agreements such as those below.
This compartmentalization allows insurers to apply certain coverages even if known conditions exist where, once upon a time, if there were preexisting issues, coverage would be denied. For example, there may be polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) contamination on the property looking to be insured. Since PCBs are sparingly soluble in water and adsorb in soil organic matter and sediment particles rather than dissolving into percolating groundwater, a PLL underwriter may take the position that, since PCBs are fairly immobile and the risk of such contamination moving off-site is slim, they can offer BI/PD and cleanup costs coverage for third-party claims but exclude the on-site cleanup coverage for that property. This can be applied to other types of contamination as well.
Duration of the PLL term can vary as well. For transactional purchases, terms vary between 5 and 10 years with a few insurers offering 10-year policies for operational coverage, while others offer 10-year terms for transactions. In regard to hospitality, habitational, and healthcare risks, most markets offer a maximum term of 3 years, with a few offering up to a 5-year term; however, for prospective or "operational" coverage, the average term is 3 years.
With around 40 insurers offering some type of PLL coverage, in our experience it can be structured with limits of liability up to $300 million each pollution condition/$300 million aggregate structured with various insurers offering follow form excess of a primary PLL program.
Remediation Stop-Loss/Cost Cap Programs
When contamination is already known and a cleanup plan has been established (and approved by a regulatory authority), remediation stop-loss or cost cap insurance can provide valuable protection. These policies are frequently used when remediation costs are difficult to estimate, subsurface conditions are found to be uncertain (which is the majority of the time), complex contamination exists, or there are expected regulatory requirements in that jurisdiction.
Cost cap coverage is designed to provide greater certainty to property owners, lenders, developers, and investors by limiting the financial impact of unforeseen remediation cost overruns. Cost cap policies typically pay for the expense incurred by the property owner when actual remediation expenses exceed anticipated cleanup costs. Coverage is typically structured around the following.
While the cost cap market is much more limited than the broader PLL sector, there are a few environmental insurers continuing to offer solutions. The process to obtain such insurance is a comprehensive and lengthy one, in some cases, taking more than a year to construct. For well-defined remediation projects supported by detailed site investigations, engineering estimates, and regulatory oversight, the process may be a bit easier, but owners may wish to take into consideration that the process is long and arduous, nonetheless.
As the redevelopment of contaminated properties continues and stakeholders seek greater financial certainty, cost cap insurance can be an important risk financing tool that the financial impact that unexpected cleanup cost escalation can present. Lastly, the cost cap program is typically accompanied by a traditional PLL policy for the unknown environmental conditions that could be discovered during the actual remediation of the property as well as third-party claims for bodily injury and property damage for both known and unknown pollution conditions.
A More Comprehensive Solution?
So, where can owners of contaminated property turn to minimize the risk of environmental liability? In addition to the above insurance mechanisms, owners have other alternatives; however, there may not be one single tactic, but rather a combination including but not limited to the following.
Although liability transfer provisions do not eliminate an owner's environmental obligations, they can help offset financial losses associated with contamination events. Used alongside environmental insurance and cleanup programs, these measures can enable property owners to better manage existing and future environmental risks, improve the marketability of their assets, and strengthen redevelopment and lending opportunities.
Opinions expressed in Expert Commentary articles are those of the author and are not necessarily held by the author's employer or IRMI. Expert Commentary articles and other IRMI content do not purport to provide legal, accounting, or other professional advice or opinion. If such advice is needed, consult with your attorney, accountant, or other qualified adviser.