Expert Commentary

Energy Insurance Market Conditions: 2021

The year 2021 was a year of recovery for the energy sector as the industry rebounded from the devastating impacts of COVID-19 during 2020. Shortly after our May 2020 article was published, energy prices increased as demand returned amid the loosening of lockdown efforts and the eventual rollout of the COVID-19 vaccine. As a result of price recovery, the outlook for the industry has drastically changed since our previous article.


Valuation of Insurance Organizations
January 2022

Acknowledgment

Thanks to Afshin Sayani, Chartered Financial Analyst, and Matt Burton, of BVA Group LLC, for their help authoring this article.

Although the outlook has improved, companies have generally adopted a defensive position to counter market uncertainty as new variants of COVID-19 emerge. The purpose of this article is to provide an update to our May 2020 article, reflect on the changes in the industry during 2021, and discuss the impact on insurance offerings as a result of recent events.

Energy Prices

West Texas Intermediate (WTI) monthly average crude oil spot prices increased substantially since the beginning of 2020 from a low of approximately $47/bbl on January 4, 2021, to a high of approximately $86/bbl on October 26, 2021.1 As the global economy continues to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic, the growing demand for oil has outpaced the supply growth. Moreover, bad weather and lower oil production have hurt supply. Hurricane Ida impacted operations in the Gulf of Mexico in August 2021, while snow and ice storms in early 2021 froze natural gas pipelines in Texas.

The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) has been slow to bring crude production back to prepandemic levels, while analysts predict OPEC production won't return to prepandemic levels until mid-2022. Furthermore, as the year drew to a close, the potential for supply disruptions increased, particularly with respect to natural gas, as Russian troop buildups near the border with Ukraine increased the possibility of hostilities between those countries, along with possible sanctions that could limit Russia’s energy exports. Overriding all of these events are the longer-term trends as the world has continued to shift to clean energy, which may also dampen supply in the long-term.2

Despite the supply and demand imbalance experienced through 2021, OPEC cut its world oil demand forecast for the fourth quarter of 2021, citing high energy prices to curb demand. Additionally, OPEC also increased its supply forecast from US shale producers into 2022, suggesting a return to balanced levels of supply and demand in the market.3 The December 2021 Energy Information Administration (EIA) forecast considers its near-term outlook as subject to heightened levels of uncertainty as the emergence of the COVID-19 omicron variant increases uncertainty about the level of energy consumption throughout the world but still predicts $73/bbl in the first quarter of 2022.4 Similarly, the International Energy Agency (IEA) predicts the average crude oil price for 2022 to reach $79.40/bbl; however, the IEA acknowledges that the recent price rally may falter as record-high prices begin to increase global production.5 Additionally, the EIA revised down the consumption forecast of petroleum into the first quarter of 2022 as a result of additional travel restrictions following the outbreaks of the omicron variant of COVID-19, while US production is forecast to increase throughout 2022.6

"WTI Price and Forecast for 2012–2026" highlights historical average monthly pricing between 2012 and November 2021, as well as the most recent New York Mercantile Exchange forecasts available as of December 17, 2021.

WTI Price and Forecast for 2012–2026

Fries WTI Price and Forecast for 2012 2026

Regarding natural gas, Henry Hub spot prices have increased approximately 149 percent from the 2020 average spot price of $2.037 per million British thermal units (MMBtu) to $5.05/MMBtu in November 2021.8 After rising throughout 2021, natural gas prices declined in November due to mild weather across the United States that resulted in less demand for natural gas used for heating than expected.9 Despite the slight decrease in natural gas demand at the end of 2021, global demand for US liquified natural gas (LNG) has remained high, limiting downward pressure on natural gas prices.10 The EIA's December 2021 "Short-Term Energy Outlook" predicts that natural gas prices will generally decline through 2022, averaging $3.98/MMBtu due to rising US natural gas production and slowing growth in LNG exports.11 Not all commodity traders agree with the EIA, though, as, for example, NYMEX futures indicate prices between $3.49/MMBtu and $4.02/MMBtu in 2022.

"Henry Hub Price and Forecast for 2012–2026" highlights historical pricing between 2012 and November 2021, as well as the most recent NYMEX forecasts available as of December 17, 2021.

Henry Hub Price and Forecast for 2012–2026

Fries Henry Hub Price and Forecast for 2012 2026

Debt and Capital Expenditures

Large-scale development projects are one of the key drivers of demand for insurance coverage in the oil and gas industry. Directionally, these outlays tend to move with oil prices as companies delay or cancel projects during sustained declines and plan or initiate projects during periods of sustained increase. Although 2021 is primarily a recovery year, as indicated by a general increase in prices compared to the historically low prices in 2020, continued market uncertainty leads to a skeptically optimistic view of the industry. The following are examples.

  • Despite cash from operations more than doubling over the past year for exploration and production companies, capital expenditures have increased by only 54 percent and remain below the 2015–2019 average capital expenditures level.12
  • North American exploration and production and oil-field services companies that filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2020 reached a combined debt level of $102 billion with an average debt level of a record $940 million. However, should WTI prices remain above $53/bbl, it is expected that the amount of Chapter 11 filings will return to prepandemic levels.13
  • US shale capital expenditures are forecast to increase 19.4 percent to $83.4 billion in 2022, the highest level since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the 2022 capital expenditure forecast is still expected to remain below the prepandemic forecast for 2022.14
  • The emergence of the omicron variant of COVID-19 could potentially reduce demand by as much as 2.9 million barrels per day in the first quarter of 2021 if lockdowns or heightened restrictions return.15 However, early indications that the variant, while highly contagious, may be less virulent than the delta variant allow for cautious optimism that strict limitations akin to the early stages of the pandemic will not be necessary.

As demand remains uncertain due to the introduction of COVID-19 variants, companies are focused on better responding to potential market volatility as opposed to investing in capital expenditures. According to the EIA, in the first three quarters of 2021, 47 exploration and production companies tracked by the administration paid off $15 billion in debt, repurchased $1.9 billion in shares, and paid out $6.9 billion in dividends bringing their long-term debt level down to the lowest level since 2012.16 Additionally, bond yields for companies with a credit rating lower than investment grade were low for the energy sector through the third quarter of 2021, which is indicative of less default risk and reduced borrowing costs; however, yields slightly increased in the fourth quarter of 2021 to 5.43 percent as of December 2, 2021, in response to recent economic growth concerns and increased market volatility.17

Developments in the Energy Insurance Industry

For the insurance industry, the COVID-19 pandemic accelerated a hardening cycle that had already started to take hold at the end of 2019.18 As a result of the hardening markets, a "two-tier" market is beginning to emerge between those with desirable risk profiles and premium income and those which the insurers value less without stronger underwriting measures.19 While capacity is limited and the industry is generally experiencing rate increases, the increases are comparatively below what was experienced during 2020.20 In the third quarter of 2021, the upstream market has experienced rate increases between approximately 2.5 and 10 percent, while the downstream market has experienced rate increases averaging between approximately 10 and 15 percent, down from early 2021 increases of 20 to 30 percent.21

Despite the overall hardening of the market, the renewable energy insurance market continues to stabilize with new capacity entering the sector as insurers increase their exposure to renewables, particularly offshore wind assets.22 The trend toward renewable energy is expected to persist beyond 2021, as evidenced by Lloyd's of London's commitment to scaling back coverage to companies involved in coal, oil sands, and Arctic exploration.23

Interest Rates Expected To Increase

Following the marked increase in inflation in 2021, the Federal Reserve, in its December 15, 2021, press release, elected to keep the target level for the federal funds rate at 0 to 0.25 percent, citing that it is appropriate to maintain this target range until the labor market reaches levels of maximum employment.24 However, the Federal Reserve has acknowledged that more steps to counter inflation will be necessary in 2022. Thus, in addition to the ongoing tapering efforts that should result in an end to purchases of Treasury securities in early 2022, the Federal Reserve is expected to increase the target federal funds rate in 2022.25

The continued near-zero interest rate environment adds an element of unfavorability in the short term for insurers, as returns from invested premium will be limited by the lower federal funds rate. Nonetheless, the anticipated interest rate hikes in 2022 would be beneficial for insurers, as invested premiums would be expected to increase with the federal funds rate.

Conclusion

While energy prices in 2021 recovered significantly from the historic lows seen in 2020, given the economic uncertainty created by the emergence of various COVID-19 variants, the industry outlook is cautiously optimistic. To hedge against unpredictable market shocks, industry players are hesitant to invest significant capital into operations and instead are focused on improving short-term financial positions and generating returns for shareholders. The depressed level of capital investment will result in lower demand for insurance products from the energy sector as the insurance markets continue to harden and underwriting tightens. Until the uncertainty surrounding COVID-19 subsides fully and the energy sector returns to prepandemic operational levels, insurers can expect lower capital investment by energy companies resulting in lower demand for insurance products into 2022.


1 US Energy Information Administration information was obtained from website data, "Cushing, OK WTI Spot Price FOB."

2 Adam Shell, "Energy Stocks Come Roaring Back," Kiplinger, November 24, 2021.

3 Alex Lawler, "OPEC Says High Prices To Dampen Pace of Oil Demand Recovery," Reuters, November 11, 2021.

41 "Short-Term Energy Outlook," US Energy Information Administration, December 2021.

5 Noah Browning, "IEA Lifts 2022 Average Crude Oil Assumption to $79.40/bbl," Reuters, November 18, 2021.

6 "Short-Term Energy Outlook," December 2021.

7 "Short-Term Energy Outlook," US Energy Information Administration, January 2021.

8 "Short-Term Energy Outlook," December 2021.

9 "Short-Term Energy Outlook," December 2021.

10 "Short-Term Energy Outlook," December 2021.

11 "Short-Term Energy Outlook," December 2021.

12 "Capital Expenditure by US Oil Companies Remains Low Despite Higher Crude Oil Prices," US Energy Information Administration, December 15, 2021.

13 "After the Costliest Chapter 11 Year in History, 2021 Bankruptcy Numbers Will Normalize if WTI Keeps Up," Rystad Energy, January 25, 2021.

14 "US Shale Spending Set To Shake Off Uncertainty and Jump 19% in 2022, Topping $83 Billion," Rystad Energy, December 1, 2021.

15 "Triggering More Lockdowns, Omicron Could Cost Oil Demand Almost 3 Million bpd in Early 2022," Rystad Energy, December 2, 2021.

16 "Capital Expenditure by US Oil Companies Remains Low Despite Higher Crude Oil Prices."

17 "Short-Term Energy Outlook," December 2021.

18 Energy Insurance Market Overview, Alesco, March 2021

19 "Energy Market Review," Willis Towers Watson, April 7, 2021.

20 Andrea Wells, "Insurance Industry Keeping Up with an Energy Market in Transition," Insurance Journal, September 6, 2021.

21 "Global Energy Insurance Market Update," Gallagher, August 2021.

22 "Global Energy Insurance Market Update."

23 "Lloyd's Takes Action To Accelerate Transition to Sustainable Economy," Lloyd's, December 16, 2020.

24 "Federal Reserve Issues FOMC Statement," Federal Open Market Committee, December 15, 2021.

25 Patti Domm, "Fed Is Expected To Speed Up End of Bond Buying and Signal Interest Rate Hikes Are Coming," CNBC, December 10, 2021.


Opinions expressed in Expert Commentary articles are those of the author and are not necessarily held by the author's employer or IRMI. Expert Commentary articles and other IRMI Online content do not purport to provide legal, accounting, or other professional advice or opinion. If such advice is needed, consult with your attorney, accountant, or other qualified adviser.

Like This Article?

IRMI Update

Dive into thought-provoking industry commentary every other week, including links to free articles from industry experts. Discover practical risk management tips, insight on important case law and be the first to receive important news regarding IRMI products and events.

Learn More